Re: Langevin and Doppler effects...

Den 09.09.2024 20:54, skrev Richard Hachel:

Le 09/09/2024 à 19:42, "Paul.B.Andersen" a écrit :
>

I will come back to the scenario seen from Stella's rest frame
in a separate post, this is long enough.
>
But I will say this:
The scenario described here is physically impossible to do
in the real world. The problem is the abrupt change of velocity
at turnaround. Stella will then have an infinite high acceleration
for zero time. This is a mathematical singularity, which make
it impossible to solve exactly. This is a problem when seen
from Stella's point of view, because what happens to her view
of Terrence's clock when her acceleration is infinite?
>
All we have to do to make it solvable is to introduce
a high but finite acceleration for a short time at turnaround.

 

>
But no!
>
You don't pay any attention to what I'm telling you.
>
You've decided to say that in RR everything is fine, that everything is acceptable, that everything is true, and that you should definitely not say anything.
>
 From then on, it turns into religious fundamentalism.
>
I explained RR like no one had explained it before, and instead of being interested, everyone is playing the monkey by opposing me with anything....
>
Pffff...

 What are you whining about?