Sujet : Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean
De : jpierre.messager (at) *nospam* gmail.com (Python)
Groupes : sci.physics.relativityDate : 11. Dec 2024, 21:56:42
Autres entêtes
Organisation : Nemoweb
Message-ID : <u7NvhHcfrBd_GXJLccUViHRQ17g@jntp>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
User-Agent : Nemo/1.0
Le 11/12/2024 à 21:29, Maciej Wozniak a écrit :
W dniu 11.12.2024 o 20:17, Python pisze:
Le 11/12/2024 à 08:17, Maciej Wozniak a écrit :
W dniu 10.12.2024 o 20:45, Python pisze:
Le 10/12/2024 à 20:20, Maciej Wozniak a écrit :
...
How do you practically check your "t = t'" equations for clocks standing next to each other?
>
I read the numbers they display and I compare them.
>
Good.
>
Then for distant mutually at rest clocks with no
gravity involved?
>
I don't.
>
Sad. You don't. You can't. We can.
>
No you can't either. Sorry, There is a small technical detail: those
"distant clocks" are not moving wrt each
other.
How do you ensure that? By assuming the
condition a priori;and you can do it because
you're only applying your procedure
in your gedanken. Am I incorrect ?
You are. I put two clocks at the extremity of a rod.
Yeah, sure - "distant" clocks at the
extremity of the rod - very practical
indeed, isn't it?
This is quite
reasonable to assume they are at rest wrt to each other, isn't it?
No. Take 2 bodies - one orbitting the other.
Join them with a rod, do you secure their relative
immobility ? Yeah, you imagined and insisted
Gdańsk and Warsaw aren't moving wrt each other. You're
such an idiot.
What is the relative speed between Gdansk and Warsaw then?
You're only believing [into] a great
practical procedure - because your is pumping you with gedanken fairy
tales where it works fine.
Nope. If such a procedure would fail it could be checked.
How could it fail if you have never used it.
No magic, and if gravity could not be ignored in a given practical setup
So, where, precisely, was your [method]
applied. In practice.
I asked for yours, if you had answered I would have explained mine. Unfortunately you've only shown how to check if a clock is in synch with itself :-))))) At least you were right then :-))))
I notice that you've chickened out, snipped most of my post, and provide only idiotic comment.
As usual :-D
--
poor stinker, idiot
Nice signature. Concise and adequate.
Date | Sujet | # | | Auteur |
8 Dec 24 | Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 70 | | Maciej Wozniak |
8 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 2 | | Richard Hachel |
8 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Maciej Wozniak |
8 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 67 | | Python |
8 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 66 | | Maciej Wozniak |
8 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Python |
8 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 64 | | Python |
9 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 63 | | Maciej Wozniak |
9 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 62 | | Python |
9 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 61 | | Maciej Wozniak |
10 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 60 | | Python |
10 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 59 | | Maciej Wozniak |
10 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 57 | | Python |
10 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 4 | | Richard Hachel |
10 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 2 | | Python |
11 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Richard Hachel |
10 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Python |
10 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 52 | | Maciej Wozniak |
10 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 50 | | Python |
11 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 49 | | Maciej Wozniak |
11 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 48 | | Python |
11 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 47 | | Maciej Wozniak |
11 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 46 | | Python |
11 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 45 | | Maciej Wozniak |
11 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 44 | | Python |
12 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 43 | | Maciej Wozniak |
15 Dec10:53 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 42 | | Python |
15 Dec12:00 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 41 | | Maciej Wozniak |
15 Dec13:05 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 35 | | Python |
15 Dec14:53 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 34 | | Maciej Wozniak |
15 Dec19:16 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Richard Hachel |
15 Dec19:50 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 32 | | Python |
15 Dec20:29 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 31 | | Maciej Wozniak |
15 Dec20:40 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 4 | | Python |
15 Dec22:02 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 3 | | Maciej Wozniak |
15 Dec22:14 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 2 | | Python |
15 Dec23:00 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Maciej Wozniak |
15 Dec21:18 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 26 | | Python |
16 Dec11:49 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 25 | | J. J. Lodder |
16 Dec13:19 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 24 | | J. J. Lodder |
16 Dec14:18 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 5 | | Richard Hachel |
17 Dec15:04 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 2 | | Paul.B.Andersen |
17 Dec15:53 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Richard Hachel |
19 Dec20:39 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 2 | | J. J. Lodder |
19 Dec22:04 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Richard Hachel |
16 Dec16:20 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Maciej Wozniak |
17 Dec01:09 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 17 | | Ross Finlayson |
17 Dec04:47 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 16 | | Ross Finlayson |
17 Dec05:04 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 15 | | Ross Finlayson |
17 Dec20:08 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 14 | | Ross Finlayson |
18 Dec09:29 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 13 | | Athel Cornish-Bowden |
18 Dec17:41 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 2 | | Richard Hachel |
18 Dec18:34 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 1 | | Athel Cornish-Bowden |
18 Dec20:37 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 4 | | Ross Finlayson |
18 Dec20:47 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 2 | | Athel Cornish-Bowden |
18 Dec20:54 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 1 | | Ross Finlayson |
18 Dec22:32 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 1 | | Ross Finlayson |
19 Dec15:51 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 6 | | J. J. Lodder |
19 Dec16:00 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 3 | | Athel Cornish-Bowden |
19 Dec16:21 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 1 | | Maciej Wozniak |
19 Dec20:39 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 1 | | J. J. Lodder |
19 Dec21:07 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 2 | | Ross Finlayson |
19 Dec21:40 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (motion, Mach-ian) | 1 | | Ross Finlayson |
15 Dec22:36 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (space-contraction) | 5 | | Ross Finlayson |
15 Dec22:39 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (space-contraction) | 4 | | Python |
16 Dec00:26 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (space-contraction) | 2 | | Ross Finlayson |
16 Dec01:11 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (space-contraction, charge mass) | 1 | | Ross Finlayson |
16 Dec12:57 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean (space-contraction) | 1 | | Richard Hachel |
10 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Python |
11 Dec 24 | Re: Why a time of the real world must be galilean | 1 | | Ross Finlayson |