Division by zero

Liste des GroupesRevenir à sp relativity 
Sujet : Division by zero
De : ttt_heg (at) *nospam* web.de (Thomas Heger)
Groupes : sci.physics.relativity
Date : 01. Feb 2025, 09:14:08
Autres entêtes
Message-ID : <m063e7FhjrnU1@mid.individual.net>
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
Hi NG
I'm actually not really certain, but found an error in Einstein's 'On the electrodynamics of moving bodies' which is quite serious.
See page six, roughly in the middle:
There we find an equation, which says this:
∂τ/∂y= 0
Now, 'tau' is a time belonging to the moving system k.
This system k moves along the x-axis of system K with velocity v, while x- and xsi-axis coincide and etha- and y axis remain parallel.
In other words v_y is permanently zero, or: ∂y=0.
So we have a 'divide by zero' case.
∂τ/∂y is a time value divided by a space value, hence has the form of 1/v.
Because it contains ∂y, the velocity along the y-axis was meant.
But for a straight lateral movement along the x-axis (only) there should be no movement along the y axis, hence ∂y remains zero, because the y-coordinate remains permanently zero, which is, of course, a constant value.
∂τ/∂y could approach a value, however, but if v_y goes to zero, the quotient ∂τ/∂y would go to infinity and NOT to zero (as the equation says).
Iow: this equation '∂τ/∂y= 0' is wrong!
TH

Date Sujet#  Auteur
1 Feb 25 * Division by zero28Thomas Heger
1 Feb 25 +* Re: Division by zero24Mikko
2 Feb 25 i+* Re: Division by zero5Ross Finlayson
2 Feb 25 ii`* Re: Division by zero4Thomas Heger
2 Feb 25 ii +* Re: Division by zero2Mikko
3 Feb 25 ii i`- Re: Division by zero1Paul.B.Andersen
2 Feb 25 ii `- Re: Division by zero (0, 1, infinity)1Ross Finlayson
2 Feb 25 i`* Re: Division by zero18Thomas Heger
2 Feb 25 i +* Re: Division by zero7Thomas Heger
2 Feb 25 i i`* Re: Division by zero6Mikko
3 Feb 25 i i `* Re: Division by zero5Thomas Heger
3 Feb 25 i i  `* Re: Division by zero4Mikko
4 Feb 25 i i   `* Re: Division by zero3Thomas Heger
5 Feb 25 i i    `* Re: Division by zero2Mikko
5 Feb 25 i i     `- Re: Division by zero1Thomas Heger
2 Feb 25 i `* Re: Division by zero10Mikko
3 Feb 25 i  `* Re: Division by zero9Thomas Heger
3 Feb 25 i   +* Re: Division by zero2Athel Cornish-Bowden
3 Feb 25 i   i`- Re: Division by zero1Thomas Heger
3 Feb 25 i   `* Re: Division by zero6Mikko
3 Feb 25 i    +- Re: Division by zero1Maciej Wozniak
4 Feb 25 i    `* Re: Division by zero4Thomas Heger
4 Feb 25 i     `* Re: Division by zero3Mikko
4 Feb 25 i      +- Re: Division by zero1Maciej Wozniak
5 Feb 25 i      `- Re: Division by zero1Thomas Heger
1 Feb 25 +* Re: Division by zero2J. J. Lodder
2 Feb 25 i`- Re: Division by zero1Ross Finlayson
20 Feb 25 `- Re: Division by zero1JanPB

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal