Re: Halley comet: The triumph of Newton mechanics and the catastrophic failure of relativity,
Sujet : Re: Halley comet: The triumph of Newton mechanics and the catastrophic failure of relativity,
De : hertz778 (at) *nospam* gmail.com (rhertz)
Groupes : sci.physics.relativityDate : 26. Feb 2025, 03:49:23
Autres entêtes
Organisation : novaBBS
Message-ID : <d9fe0bb410264a1bd81221f7cd6c5703@www.novabbs.com>
References : 1 2
User-Agent : Rocksolid Light
Asked to DeepSeek:
QUESTION: Is there any mathematical formulation for the orbital path of
Halley's comet using Schwarzschild metric?
ANSWER:
**************************************************
MY NOTE HERE: Observe how DeepSeek reduced the problem to a simple
problem with only two celestial bodies in the entire universe. Not
credible since this point.
**************************************************
Dismissing the influence of major planets, the loss of mass when
approaching the Sun and other minor influences, the orbital path of
Halley's comet can be described using the Schwarzschild metric.The
Schwarzschild metric describes the gravitational field outside a
spherical, non-rotating mass like the Su
The Schwarzschild metric in Schwarzschild coordinates (t,r,θ,ϕ) is given
by
ds² = -(1-2GM/c²r) c²dt² + 1/(1-2GM/c²r) dr² + r²(dθ² + sin² θ dϕ²)
where:
G is the gravitational constant,
M is the mass of the central object (e.g., the Sun),
c is the speed of light,
r is the radial coordinate,
θ and ϕ are the angular coordinates.
The motion of Halley's comet would follow a geodesic in this spacetime.
The geodesic equation is:
d²xᵘ/dτ² + Γᵘᵥᵢ dxᵛ/dτ dxⁱ/dτ = 0
where
xᵘ are the coordinates (t,r,θ,ϕ).
τ is the proper time along the comet's worldline.
Γᵘᵥᵢ are the Christoffel symbols, which depend on the metric.
Simplifications:
For Halley's comet, we make some simplifications:
* The orbit is approximately planar, so we can set θ=π/2 (equatorial
plane)
* The motion is only influenced by the Sun's gravity.
Effective Potential:
The radial motion can be described using an effective potential Veff(r),
which incorporates both the gravitational potential and the angular
momentum of the comet. The effective potential in the Schwarzschild
metric is:
Veff(r) = (1-2GM/c²r) (1 + L²/c²r²)
where L is the specific angular momentum of the comet.
Orbital Equation:
The orbital equation for r(ϕ) can be derived from the geodesic equation
and is given by:
d²u/dϕ² + u = GM/h² + 3GM/c² u²
where:
* u = 1/r
* h= L/c is the specific angular momentum per unit speed of light.
This equation is a relativistic version of the classical Binet equation
and includes a correction term 3GM/c² u², due to General Relativity.
////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
MY CONCLUSION: This equation is exactly the one derived for the problem
of Mercury's perihelion advance. IT'S USELESS, considering the HUGE
AMOUNT
OF SIMPLIFICATIONS INTRODUCED, WHICH MAKE IT WORTHLESS.
In particular due to the trajectory of the comet Halley which, having an
eccentricity close to 1 (ONE) resembles a PARABOLIC TRAJECTORY instead
of
an elliptical one.
THE IMPOTENCE OF CHATGPT AND DEEPSEEK TO FORCEFULLY INTRODUCE GENERAL
RELATIVITY IN THE TRAJECTORY OF THE HALLEY'S COMET DISPLAY THE DEGREE
OF INFILTRATION OF RELATIVITY (AT ANY COST) IN CELESTIAL MECHANICS.
As far as I know, both AI engines are fed with information collected
from relevant sites of Internet, which are 100% CONTAMINATED with the
GR shit.
As I always say, relativity is A PSEUDOSCIENCE with no real values in
the actual physical world.
Newton reigns in the Solar System mechanics.
Fuck Einstein and fuck general relativity.
Haut de la page
Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.
NewsPortal