Re: Relativity and the nature of light. Waves or particles?

Richard Hachel: Re: "The two lightnings will be simultaneous for the
station master, but ALSO for the traveler." Sound is constrained to one
speed in the atmosphere. The person walking towards the ambulance will
hear the siren at S + 3 mph. You are denying that. You are making an
irrational denial of relative motion, as shown by the analogy to sound.