Liste des Groupes | Revenir à p relativity |
Den 14.03.2024 17:18, skrev Richard Hachel:As he did on fr.sci.physique for decades.Le 14/03/2024 à 15:02, "Paul B. Andersen" a écrit :I do indeed understand that you telling me:A rocket is accelerating at the constant proper acceleration a.>
An inertial frame of reference K(x,t) is at the time t = 0
instantly co-moving with the rocket.
>
You claim:
According to SR the speed of the rocket in K is Vr(t) = a⋅t
===========================================================
>
Note that this means that Vr > c when t > c/a
which according to SR is impossible.
>
A rocket is accelerating at the constant proper acceleration a.
An inertial frame of reference K(x,t) is at the time t = 0
instantly co-moving with the rocket.
>
You claim:
According to SR the speed of the rocket in K is Vr(t) = a⋅t
===========================================================
>
Note that this means that Vr > c when t > c/a
which according to SR is impossible.
>
>
Contradicting fact:
-------------------
So this is wrong.
You can see the correct derivation here:
https://paulba.no/pdf/TwinsByMetric.pdf
See chapter 2.3, equation (15)
>
Vr(t) = a⋅t/√(1+(a⋅t/c)²)
>
Note that:
Vr → a⋅t when t → 0
Vr → c when t → ∞
>
>
Your problem is that you do not understand the difference
between proper acceleration of the rocket, and the rocket's
coordinate acceleration in the inertial frame.
>
If A is the coordinate acceleration in K, we have:
>
A = dVr/dt = a/(√(1+(a⋅t/c)²))³
>
Note that:
A → a when t → 0
A → 0 when t → ∞
>
So Vr(t) = ∫(from 0 to t)A⋅dt = a⋅t/√(1+(a⋅t/c)²)
>
You claim:
According to SR is the average speed of the rocket Vm(t) = Vr(t)/2
=====================================================================
>
Contradicting fact:
-------------------
This is wrong.
>
Vr(t) = a⋅t/√(1+(a⋅t/c)²)
>
The average speed Vm at the time t is:
Vm = (integral from t=0 to t=t of Vr(t)dt)/t
Vm = c²⋅(√(1+(a⋅t/c)²)-1)/a⋅t
>
Note that:
Vm → a⋅t/2 when t → 0
Vm → c when t → ∞
>
So:
Vm/Vr → 1/2 when t → 0
rm/Vr → 1 when t → ∞
>
So for any t > 0 Vm > Vr/2
>
It is not possible to make SR predict anything else!
====================================================
You don't understand anything I'm telling you...
Vr(t) = a⋅t
and:
Vm(t) = Vr(t)/2
And I do indeed understand that what you are telling me is wrong.
And it is a very naive and elementary blunder!
>I do understand that you find it difficult to defend your own words.
In these conditions, it is very difficult to discuss.
So that's why you don't even try, right?
Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.