Re: Langevin's paradox again

W dniu 11.07.2024 o 20:29, Richard Hachel pisze:

Le 11/07/2024 à 16:09, ram@zedat.fu-berlin.de (Stefan Ram) a écrit :

>
  From the perspective of the twin chilling back on Earth, the
  traveling twin is getting the time dilation treatment the whole time,
  so he ages way less. That part's a no-brainer. But now let's flip
  the script and look at it /from the traveling twin's point of view/:
>
  When the traveling twin bounces from Earth (I'm assuming
  constant velocity for simplicity), time on Earth starts slowing
  down for them. Not like, looking through a telescope slow,
  but like, the time between two moments on Earth that line up
  with a single second on the spaceship is actually less than a
  second. Trippy, right?
  Then when the traveling twin boomerangs back to Earth, time is
  still dragging for them. That's the time dilation working its
  magic - independent of the direction of the movement.
>
  So the traveling twin should be thinking his Earth-bound bro is
  aging slower. But somehow, it's the opposite - the Earth twin is
  looking way more mature. What gives? Could it have something to do
  with that quick boost in the middle to flip the script and head back?
>
  This is the question that's been stumping everyone, but get
  this - I found the answer last year in some old Einstein text.   Here's how it breaks down:
>
  The traveler thinks of himself as stationary and unaccelerated. But
  how does he keep that mindset when the engines are blasting during
  the turnaround? It's like there's a uniform gravitational field
  filling the whole space - the engines are just keeping the ship from
  falling in it, so it stays at rest!
  So if the traveler sees himself as at rest during that acceleration,
  a uniform gravitational field is filling the whole space for him.
>
  In this field, the traveler and Earth twin are at totally different
  potentials (and the farther apart, the bigger the difference).
  This potential gap makes time on Earth zoom by so fast, it more
  than makes up for the slowdown on the outbound and return legs!
>
  And that's why, /also from the traveler's point of view/, more time

 But no!!!
 Damn, what are you all doing on sci.physics.relativity talking loads of bullshit?
 The problem is not there at all, and here is one (which seems to come from Germany) who didn't understand anything more.
 Damn it! Breathe in, breathe out!
 This is not AT ALL what is happening. The U-turn, absolutely nothing happens on TIMES, but only on spaces (and only in Stella's frame of reference).
 Breathe in, breathe out!
 All this is the fault of this idiot Python, who has been completely ruining the scientific forums for thirty years by spitting on posters as soon as he sees one that does not seem to him to be in conformity.
 And we end up with posts as stupid as this one.
 I repeat, during the U-turn, nothing happens at all on the TIME side.
 For Terrence to stay on earth, he observed in his ultra-powerful telescope Stella traveling an immense semi-circle at the tangential speed of 0.8c, and returning to earth.
 We admit that the rocket can withstand these terrible accelerations,
and Terrence observes that the U-turn takes place in 40 hours.
 For Stella, the clean time is shorter, only 24 hours.
 The effect is absolute.
 Once this is understood, we see that it all fits together very well, and that there is no need to imagine useless unicorns.
 But what happens during this U-turn for Terrence?
He ages by 40 hours, and observes that his sister ages by 24 hours between the moment she begins the U-turn, and the moment she completes her U-turn.
 FOR Stella, it's exactly the same thing, when she begins her U-turn, her clock marks 9 years, and she sees over there (direct-live) Terrence's clock marks three years.
 When she finishes her U-turn, she has aged 24 hours, and she sees the earth clock which still marks three years (plus 40 hours).
 Nothing special happens.
 And those who say that something is happening (like gap-time) are morons who don't understand the theory.
 Being an idiot who doesn't understand doesn't matter, personally I remained an idiot for decades before I got the hang of it and was able to write an SR of perfect logic and perfect beauty.

And in the meantime in the real world, improper clocks
keep measuring improper t'=t in improper seconds.
Common sense was warning your idiot guru.