Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic

Liste des GroupesRevenir à p relativity 
Sujet : Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic
De : clzb93ynxj (at) *nospam* att.net (LaurenceClarkCrossen)
Groupes : sci.physics.relativity
Date : 27. Oct 2024, 20:48:08
Autres entêtes
Organisation : novaBBS
Message-ID : <442510afb0c2ae9b2fe96c3ad217dab2@www.novabbs.com>
References : 1 2
User-Agent : Rocksolid Light
Mikko:
Re: "> Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic
Relativity is perfectly compatible with elementary and advanced logic,

1. Time dilation: Since time is an abstraction,
That does not prevent us from talking about it.

this necessarily involves the reification fallacy, making it illogical
nonsense.
No, it does not. The expression "time dilation" has its own meaning
that does not follow from the meanings of "time" and "dilation".

Time does not dilate.
That does not follow from logic or anything mentioned above.
--
Mikko"
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Re: "Relativity is perfectly compatible with elementary and advanced
logic,"
You have only made an assertion while I have explained how.
"That does not prevent us from talking about it."
That was not my argument.
"No, it does not. The expression "time dilation" has its own meaning
that does not follow from the meanings of "time" and "dilation"."
How mystifying! Pray, tell what it means!
That time does not dilate follows from the fact that it is an
abstraction. Since time is a comparison of rates of change, it involves
a standard unit of measure that cannot dilate. Just as meters do not
dilate time does not.

Date Sujet#  Auteur
27 Oct 24 * Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic40LaurenceClarkCrossen
27 Oct 24 +* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic3Bertietaylor
27 Oct 24 i`* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic2LaurenceClarkCrossen
15 Nov 24 i `- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Bertietaylor
27 Oct 24 +* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic3Mikko
27 Oct 24 i+- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Maciej Wozniak
27 Oct 24 i`- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1LaurenceClarkCrossen
27 Oct 24 +* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic6Sylvia Else
27 Oct 24 i+- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Maciej Wozniak
27 Oct 24 i+- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1LaurenceClarkCrossen
27 Oct 24 i+- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Bertietaylor
27 Oct 24 i+- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1LaurenceClarkCrossen
27 Oct 24 i`- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1LaurenceClarkCrossen
27 Oct 24 `* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic27gharnagel
27 Oct 24  +- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Maciej Wozniak
27 Oct 24  +- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1LaurenceClarkCrossen
27 Oct 24  +- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1LaurenceClarkCrossen
28 Oct 24  +- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1LaurenceClarkCrossen
28 Oct 24  +- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Ross Finlayson
28 Oct 24  +- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1LaurenceClarkCrossen
30 Oct 24  `* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic20LaurenceClarkCrossen
14 Nov 24   `* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic19J. J. Lodder
14 Nov 24    +- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Maciej Wozniak
14 Nov 24    `* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic17LaurenceClarkCrossen
14 Nov 24     +- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Mikko
14 Nov 24     `* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic15J. J. Lodder
14 Nov 24      `* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic14LaurenceClarkCrossen
14 Nov 24       `* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic13J. J. Lodder
15 Nov 24        +* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic11Athel Cornish-Bowden
15 Nov 24        i+* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic9J. J. Lodder
15 Nov 24        ii+* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic7ProkaryoticCaspaseHomolog
15 Nov 24        iii+* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic4J. J. Lodder
15 Nov 24        iiii`* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic3ProkaryoticCaspaseHomolog
15 Nov 24        iiii `* Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic2J. J. Lodder
15 Nov 24        iiii  `- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Maciej Wozniak
15 Nov 24        iii+- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1gharnagel
15 Nov 24        iii`- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Bertietaylor
15 Nov 24        ii`- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1LaurenceClarkCrossen
15 Nov 24        i`- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1Ross Finlayson
15 Nov 24        `- Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic1LaurenceClarkCrossen

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal