Re: Relativity Refuted by Elementary Logic

LaurenceClarkCrossen <clzb93ynxj@att.net> wrote:

Gary & everyone: Physicists will never be able to derive relativity
logically. "...natural selection becomes not just a natural law but a
logical law! That is, it looks like given certain conditions, natural
selection logically has to follow. This is a more powerful concept of
natural law than the laws of physics themselves-- after all, physicists
have (so far) not been able to derive quantum mechanics or relativity
from logic....the universe could have been otherwise." - Massimo
Pigliucci "Historical vs. Nomological Sciences" Skeptical Inquirer
Jan/Feb 2011.

No, of course not.
Nothing in science has ever been derived logically.
Logic can at best tell you that a certain theory is not self-consistent.

Math is not physics,

Jan