Re: General Relativity Does Not Rescue Special Relativity.

W dniu 13.11.2024 o 17:59, J. J. Lodder pisze:

JanPB <film.art@gmail.com> wrote:
 

On Wed, 6 Nov 2024 22:39:18 +0000, LaurenceClarkCrossen wrote:
>

Reasonable defense by a relativist: Dingle refuted the alleged cause of
relative motion for time dilation of special relativity. Time dilation
is a part of GR, not SR.

>
Dingle's mistake was assuming a direct cause. But it may be that
the two are merely *correlated* by a *common indirect cause*.
>
In physics situations like this arose many times. For example,
Maxwell's theory required equipping EM fields with their own
momentum and angular momentum (otherwise the conservation laws
would fail). Nobody knew what the seat of that momentum was.
This was only modelled much later in quantum electrodynamics.
>
It's very likely that time dilation, etc., are similarly conditioned
phenomena. We still don't have the right model for the underlying
causes.

 This is highly unlikely.
Time dilation seems to be an inherent property
of the space-time we find ourselves in.

It surely is  an inherent property
  of the space-time you find yourselves
in.  It has just nothing in common with
the reality, anyone can check GPS, time
(as defined by your idiot guru himself)
is galilean.