Re: "Back to the Galilean Transformation and Newtonian Physics" - Moshe Eisenman c.2017

On Sun, 22 Dec 2024 14:32:12 +0000, Paul.B.Andersen wrote:

Den 22.12.2024 04:56, skrev LaurenceClarkCrossen:

He shows that the Maxwell equations are invariant under the Galilean
transformations making the LT invalid.
>
free pdf =
https://www.globalscientificjournal.com/researchpaper/Back-to-Galilean-
Transformation-and-Newtonian-Physics-Refuting-the-Theory-of-Relativity.pdf
>
"Abstract
This paper refutes the theory of relativity. Previous attempts by others
were based on pointing at contradictions between corollaries of the
theory of relativity and reality, often called paradoxes. The main point
of this article is to indicate and correct the error that led scientists
at the turn of the twentieth century to formulate the faulty theory of
relativity."

>
Another quote:
>
A.5 Speed of Propagation of Electric and Magnetic Fields
--------------------------------------------------------
"In this section we will prove that the physical laws on which
  Maxwell's equations are based imply that electric and magnetic
  fields propagate at an infinite speed. In other words, if
  the speeds of propagation of electric and magnetic fields are
  finite – the following laws are inconsistent, i.e., they are
  self-contradictory."
>
The "following laws" are Maxwell's equation.
>
So Eisenmann claims to have proved that Maxwell's equations
predict that the speed of EM-radiation is infinite.
>
Considering that Maxwell in 1865 showed that according his
equations the speed of EM-radiation is a constant, and all
physicists ever since know that Maxwell's equations
do indeed predict that the speed of EM-radiation in vacuum
is a constant, Eisenmann must be a brave person claiming
otherwise after 150 years!
>
And a bit stupid?

Nonetheless, his main point holds good. There is no intelligent reason
to have an LT instead of the Galilean transformation without an ether.
To use the LT is stupid. Very stupid.