Re: Relativity Derives Zero Deflection of Light By Gravity.

Am Samstag000022, 22.02.2025 um 21:52 schrieb Richard Hachel:

Le 22/02/2025 à 08:31, Thomas Heger a écrit :

>
That's what the scientists say.
I can't help but think that this is all a bit unclear.
>

>
Well, possibly.

 Many things scientists say are not very clear.
It would not be a major problem in the history of humanity if they agreed to discuss it, and to come back to the less clear points, to doubt them, or even abandon them.
But they do not want to.
Maybe artificial intelligence will one day become truly intelligent and truly efficient. Maybe.
It will then impose the logical concepts that today's physicists and mathematicians do not want to hear. Maybe.
This will necessarily involve a lot of astonishment.
I remind you that I managed to rewrite ALL of special relativity with ALL the correct equations, just as I denounced "problems" in the basic concepts of complex numbers taught at school, where things are incorrect and extraordinarily complicated (we don't even know how to clearly explain what i is, and we believe absurdities such as if i²=-1 then i^4=1 since (-a)²(-a)²=a^4).
For 40 years I have been pointing out, here and there, huge blunders of logic and concept, asking that we review things that seem clear, but are nevertheless false.
Human arrogance invariably answers me that if all this were false, it would be known.
It would be known?
Are we sure?

Possibly you are right with your pessimistic world view, but I'm not concerned with that.
My advantage (so to speak) is actually, that I'm not a physicist and simply didn't know what physicist think about their social environment and what one shall do or don't do.
And ignoring things you don't know is easy.
TH