Re: Einstein versus Poincaré

Am Mittwoch000004, 04.06.2025 um 18:19 schrieb Richard Hachel:

Many people have reported the Einstein scam, a primarily political scam at a time when preparations were underway for one of humanity's most devastating conflicts, and when, precisely, the French, English, and Germans were glaring at each other.
What happened? For several years, a French genius had been introducing a brand new theory, writing philosophical, mathematical, and physical texts of prime importance (Henri Poincaré was considered the last man in humanity to still master the entire science of his time, something that would no longer be possible today). In June 1905, he published an article on "On the Dynamics of the Electron" which he sent to Bern. In Bern, an anonymous copyist (don't laugh, friends) then published an article in September entitled "Dynamics of the Electron."
LOL.
I don't believe Albert Einstein wrote a single line of this article, but that it was written by the best German specialists, and that he simply served as a front. Their goal wasn't to glorify Einstein, but to show that Poincaré hadn't discovered anything special. The goal of Einstein's article was to pull the rug out from under Poincaré and France.
We couldn't afford a France illuminating the world with a completely revolutionary theory.
It's as simple as that.

I would mostly agree, but would exchange 'Swiss' or 'Switzerland' with 'German'.
I actually do think, that Einstein wasn't a German, but most likely Swiss. Possibly he wasn't even a Jew and possibly his name wasn't 'Einstein'.
I had also doubts about the sources of 'On the electrodynamics of moving bodies' and especially about the alleged date.
I think, that Einstein's text contains actually quotes from "On the Dynamics of the Electron", which was published two weeks later.
Einstein had most likely also quoted Heinrich Hertz, but without reference and also incorrectly.
...
TH