Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis

Liste des GroupesRevenir à theory 
Sujet : Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis
De : richard (at) *nospam* damon-family.org (Richard Damon)
Groupes : comp.theory sci.logic sci.math comp.ai.philosophy
Date : 23. Jun 2025, 03:11:23
Autres entêtes
Organisation : i2pn2 (i2pn.org)
Message-ID : <728b9512cbf8dbf79931bfd3d5dbed265447d765@i2pn2.org>
References : 1
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 6/22/25 10:05 PM, olcott wrote:
Since one year ago ChatGPT increased its token limit
from 4,000 to 128,000 so that now "understands" the
complete proof of the DD example shown below.
 int DD()
{
    int Halt_Status = HHH(DD);
    if (Halt_Status)
      HERE: goto HERE;
    return Halt_Status;
}
 *This seems to be the complete HHH(DD) that includes HHH(DDD)*
https://chatgpt.com/share/6857286e-6b48-8011-91a9-9f6e8152809f
 ChatGPT agrees that I have correctly refuted every halting
problem proof technique that relies on the above pattern.
 
Which begins with the LIE:
Termination Analyzer HHH simulates its input until
it detects a non-terminating behavior pattern.
Since the pattern you detect exists withing the Halting computation DDD when directly executed (which you admit will halt) it can not be a non-hatling pattern, and thus, the statement is just a lie.
Sorry, you are just proving that you basic nature is to be a liar.

Date Sujet#  Auteur
23 Jun 25 * ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis90olcott
23 Jun 25 `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis89Richard Damon
23 Jun 25  +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis21olcott
23 Jun 25  i`* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis20Richard Damon
23 Jun 25  i `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis19olcott
23 Jun 25  i  +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis17joes
23 Jun 25  i  i+* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis8olcott
24 Jun 25  i  ii`* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis7Richard Damon
24 Jun 25  i  ii `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis6olcott
24 Jun 25  i  ii  `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis5Richard Damon
24 Jun 25  i  ii   `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis4olcott
25 Jun 25  i  ii    `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis3Richard Damon
25 Jun 25  i  ii     `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis2olcott
26 Jun 25  i  ii      `- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Richard Damon
23 Jun 25  i  i`* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis8olcott
23 Jun 25  i  i `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis7joes
23 Jun 25  i  i  `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis6olcott
24 Jun 25  i  i   `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis5joes
24 Jun 25  i  i    `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis4olcott
25 Jun 25  i  i     `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis3Mikko
25 Jun 25  i  i      `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis2olcott
26 Jun 25  i  i       `- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Mikko
24 Jun 25  i  `- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Richard Damon
24 Jun 25  `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis67olcott
24 Jun 25   `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis66Richard Damon
24 Jun 25    `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis65olcott
24 Jun 25     +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis3Chris M. Thomasson
24 Jun 25     i+- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1olcott
25 Jun 25     i`- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Mikko
25 Jun 25     +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis9Richard Damon
25 Jun 25     i`* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis8olcott
25 Jun 25     i +- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1olcott
26 Jun 25     i +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis5Richard Damon
26 Jun 25     i i`* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis4olcott
26 Jun 25     i i +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis2olcott
26 Jun 25     i i i`- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Richard Damon
26 Jun 25     i i `- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Richard Damon
26 Jun 25     i `- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Richard Damon
25 Jun 25     +- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Richard Damon
25 Jun 25     `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis51Mikko
25 Jun 25      `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis50olcott
26 Jun 25       +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis18Fred. Zwarts
27 Jun 25       i`* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis17olcott
27 Jun08:59       i `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis16Fred. Zwarts
27 Jun15:08       i  `* ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---15olcott
28 Jun09:57       i   `* Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---14Fred. Zwarts
28 Jun14:08       i    `* Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---13olcott
28 Jun18:39       i     +- Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---1Richard Damon
29 Jun11:34       i     `* Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---11Fred. Zwarts
29 Jun14:29       i      `* Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---10olcott
29 Jun20:05       i       +- Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---1Richard Damon
30 Jun08:38       i       `* Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---8Fred. Zwarts
30 Jun17:33       i        `* Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---7olcott
30 Jun21:40       i         `* Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---6joes
30 Jun22:50       i          `* Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---5olcott
1 Jul09:56       i           +* Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---3joes
1 Jul12:38       i           i`* Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---2olcott
1 Jul15:42       i           i `- Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---1joes
1 Jul10:06       i           `- Re: ChatGPT and claude.ai agree that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique ---1Fred. Zwarts
26 Jun 25       `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis31Mikko
27 Jun 25        `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis30olcott
27 Jun07:55         `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis29Mikko
27 Jun15:19          `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis28olcott
28 Jun13:04           `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis27Mikko
28 Jun14:54            `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis26olcott
28 Jun18:41             +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis20Richard Damon
28 Jun22:52             i`* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis19olcott
29 Jun00:10             i +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis16Richard Damon
29 Jun00:19             i i`* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis15olcott
29 Jun02:14             i i +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis4Richard Damon
29 Jun04:36             i i i`* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis3olcott
29 Jun12:09             i i i `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis2Richard Damon
29 Jun14:23             i i i  `- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1olcott
29 Jun15:47             i i `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis10olcott
30 Jun08:35             i i  +* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis8Fred. Zwarts
30 Jun17:20             i i  i+* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis2olcott
1 Jul09:40             i i  ii`- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Fred. Zwarts
30 Jun17:42             i i  i`* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis5Mike Terry
30 Jun23:00             i i  i `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis4olcott
1 Jul09:36             i i  i  `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis3Fred. Zwarts
1 Jul13:09             i i  i   `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis2olcott
2 Jul09:26             i i  i    `- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Fred. Zwarts
30 Jun10:09             i i  `- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Mikko
29 Jun15:39             i `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis2olcott
30 Jun10:19             i  `- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Mikko
29 Jun10:27             `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis5Mikko
29 Jun15:38              `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis4olcott
30 Jun10:21               `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis3Mikko
1 Jul15:14                `* Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis2olcott
2 Jul08:14                 `- Re: ChatGPT agrees that I have refuted the conventional Halting Problem proof technique --- Full 38 page analysis1Mikko

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal